ULTIMATE GUIDE

Security Awareness Metrics:
Measuring Phishing Campaigns & Human Risk.

Discover the security awareness metrics that move beyond manual phishing campaign checkboxes to build a resilient human firewall and demonstrate true ROI.

Book a Call

Key Takeaways

Shift focus from compliance (completion rates) to behavioral proof (reporting rates).
Target a Reporting Rate >70% to prove active defense (baseline is <20%).
Measure 'Time-to-Report' (Dwell Time) to prove risk reduction speed.
Prove ROI: $1 invested returns $4 in breach prevention (Avg breach = $4.88M).
Align with Executive Goals: Frame security as a business enabler for AI adoption.

The Strategic Shift: Measuring Human Risk

Traditional security awareness training is failing to stop modern, AI-driven attacks. To secure executive investment, you must reframe the conversation from "training completion" to "risk reduction".

Vanity Metrics (Avoid)	Behavior & Risk Metrics (Adopt)
Course Completion Rate Only proves an employee clicked a link. Zero correlation to engaging with real threats.	Threat Reporting Rate The primary success metric. Proves employees are proactively defending the organization.
Phishing Click Rate Focuses on failure and punishment. Easily manipulated by lowering simulation difficulty.	Time-to-Report (Dwell Time) Measures the speed of your defense. Reducing this directly shrinks the window of risk.

The Security Awareness KPIs That Matter

A modern program is a three-legged stool: Behavioral, Financial, and Cultural metrics.

Reporting Rate

Percentage of users who strictly report threats.

Target: >70%

Dwell Time

Time between opening a phish and reporting it.

Target: <15 mins

Repeat Offender Rate

Users failing 3+ consecutive simulations.

Target: <5%

Phish-Prone %

Users likely to click (Contextual Context Only).

Target: Trending Down

Operational Efficiency

Help Desk Ticket Reduction: Quantify the drop in password resets and malware reimaging requests. Mature programs see a 30-40% reduction, freeing up IT staff for strategic work.

Financial ROI

Cost Avoidance: `(Reduction in Breach Probability) x ($4.88M Avg Cost)`. Every $1 invested in training returns $4 in prevented breach costs.

Best Practices for a Metrics-Driven Program

DO THIS

Start with education. Never test without teaching first.
Explain "Why". Frame simulations as practice (like a fire drill), not a trap.
Calibrate Difficulty. Send relevant, role-specific scenarios.

DON'T DO THIS

✕
Public Shaming. Never use "Wall of Sheep" or punish failures publicly.
✕
Tie to Performance. Creating fear reduces the likelihood of reporting real threats.
✕
Panic Lures. Avoid layoff or salary-change templates that cause genuine distress.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a 'good' reporting rate?▼

A good target for a mature security awareness program is an average reporting rate of approximately 70% per employee. Programs with rates below 20% need improvement.

Should we still track the phishing click rate?▼

Yes, but only for context. It focuses on failure and is easily manipulated. Your primary KPI should be the Reporting Rate.

What if an employee repeatedly fails?▼

This calls for individualized intervention, not punishment. It usually signals a knowledge gap or a high-risk role requiring specific training.

What is the difference between template and AI phishing?▼

Templates are static and generic. AI-generated phishing uses OSINT to create unique, hyper-personalized emails that adapt to the user's role and digital footprint.

What is the ROI of security awareness?▼

Every dollar invested returns $4 in prevented breaches. With average incident costs at $4.88M, preventing a single breach pays for the program many times over.

Glossary of Key Terms

Adversary-in-the-Middle (AitM)

Attacker intercepts communications between two parties to steal session cookies/credentials.

Business Email Compromise (BEC)

Scam where attacker impersonates an executive/vendor to trick an employee into transferring funds.

Cost Avoidance

Financial calculation of value: (Avg Breach Cost) x (Probability Reduction).

Dwell Time

Time elapsed from threat delivery to threat reporting. Also known as Time-to-Report.

Phishing Campaign

A coordinated series of simulated phishing attacks used to measure and train employee vulnerability.

Human Risk Management

Strategic approach to identifying, measuring, and mitigating risks associated with human behavior.

OSINT

Open-Source Intelligence. Data from public sources (social media) used to craft personalized attacks.

Phish-prone Percentage

Metric describing percentage of employees likely to click a phishing link during a campaign.

Quishing (QR Phishing)

Attacks using malicious QR codes to bypass email filters and directed at mobile devices.

Reporting Rate

Percentage of users who strictly report threats. The primary success metric of a mature simulation program.

Spear Phishing

Highly targeted attack aimed at specific individuals, often using personalized info.

Vishing

Voice Phishing. Attacks conducted over the phone impersonating trusted entities.

Security Culture

Shared values and behaviors determining an organization's resilience to human-targeted attacks.

View All Educational Resources

Measure. Manage. Mitigate.

Move your organization from compliance-driven training to a behavior-driven security culture. See how our platform provides the actionable metrics you need.

Get a Free Consultation

Get the ROI Calculator

See exactly how much risk you can eliminate.

Free Risk Assessment
Migration Plan Included
No Credit Card Required